Pentagon says no plans to close Guantánamo prison

The Pentagon on Monday rejected a call to close the Guantanamo prison for foreign terrorism suspects and declined to express regret over five cases of U.S. jailers “mishandling” the Koran there.

US guards or interrogators kicked the Islamic holy book at the naval base at Guantanamo Bay in Cuba, stepped on it and soaked it in water, and in one case a guard’s urine splashed through an air vent onto a prisoner and his Koran, US Southern Command said.

Bryan Whitman, a senior Pentagon spokesman, said the United States was not considering shutting the Guantanamo jail, as suggested by a senior Senate Democrat. “Guantanamo serves a vital purpose in many ways.” Mr Whitman said. He said some prisoners are “very, very, very dangerous people”.

“They want to do harm not only to Americans but to US interests overseas, to our friends and allies and these are people that if released would certainly be found back on the battlefield in the war on terror.”

Continue reading

Shut down Guantánamo – New York Times backs Amnesty

Guantanamo“What makes Amnesty’s gulag metaphor apt is that Guantánamo is merely one of a chain of shadowy detention camps that also includes Abu Ghraib in Iraq, the military prison at Bagram Air Base in Afghanistan and other, secret locations run by the intelligence agencies. Each has produced its own stories of abuse, torture and criminal homicide. These are not isolated incidents, but part of a tightly linked global detention system with no accountability in law. Prisoners have been transferred from camp to camp. So have commanding officers. And perhaps not coincidentally, so have specific methods of mistreatment.”

Editorial in the New York Times, 5 June 2005

Little Green Footballs is not impressed: “The New York Times defends Amnesty International’s comparison of Guantanamo Bay (where 600 unlawful combatants are held) with the Soviet Gulag (where more than 20 million innocent Russian citizens were imprisoned, and millions killed). As a solution to this towering injustice, the editors of the Times call for Gitmo to be shut down. Immediately. Turn them all loose. And make sure the evil Bushco doesn’t send those poor oppressed killers without consciences to places where they might be imprisoned again – like their home countries.”

LGF, 5 June 2005

See also “Senator urges Guantánamo closure after Pentagon admits Qur’an abuse”, Guardian, 6 June 2005

And “Quran splashed with urine at Guantanamo”, Informed Comment, 6 June 2005

Minister urges fine for burka

Women wearing burkas in Italy should be reported to the police and fined, Silvio Berlusconi’s justice minister said at the weekend. Roberto Castelli said the garment was at odds with an Italian law that forbids masks.

The burka is rare, though not unknown, in Italy. But commentators yesterday noted that the minister’s ruling against masks could be applied to other garb more commonly worn by Muslim women, that leaves only the eyes visible.

Mr Castelli told a meeting in the northern town of Como: “No one may break the law.”

He was referring to a decision by the local prefect to overturn fines imposed last year on an Italian convert to Islam from nearby Drezzo, who wears a burka. Two other women have been fined for wearing the garment elsewhere.

Mr Castelli’s remarks were condemned by leftwing parties. Marco Rizzo of the Communist party said they were “at the threshold of incitement to racial and religious hatred”.

Guardian, 6 June 2005

See also “Italian minister grilled over fining niqab”, Islam Online. 6 June 2005

High-flying professor faces US terror trial

samialarianUniversity of Florida professor Sami al-Arian goes on trial today in what is being billed as the most important terrorism case in the United States since September 11.

Prosecutors claim that Dr Arian, and three other Arab-Americans who will be in the dock with him, commanded an Islamic Jihad cell that flourished in Tampa and infiltrated the University of South Florida. The group is said to have helped finance a series of attacks in the West Bank, Gaza Strip and Israel in which more than 100 people died, including at least one American.

However, supporters and lawyers for the Kuwait-born professor claim that it is not a straightforward case of terrorist funding. Instead, they say it raises serious issues about anti-Muslim bias in the US post-September 11, freedom of speech and what they see as a blatant attempt by Israel to silence a powerful Palestinian voice in America.

Guardian, 6 June 2005

Jeb Bush sells out to militant Islamism (it says here)

AAH logoGovernor of Florida Jeb Bush was among those who sent greetings to the annual banquet of the Florida Chapter of the Council on American-Islamic Relations.

Joe Kaufman, chairman of “Americans Against Hate” (satire stands disarmed), declared: “Our organization expresses its deep disappointment that our state’s leaders would send letters of support to a group such as CAIR. We find it especially counterproductive, during our country’s war against terrorism. We ask all those that sent letters of support to retract the statements made in those letters.”

Americans Against Hate press release, 5 June 3005

One Muslim’s odyssey to Guantánamo

muratkurnazRichard Bernstein examines the case of Guantánamo detainee Murat Kurnaz, a 19-year-old Muslim from Germany, who was arrested in Pakistan in 2001 and handed over to US forces to face imprisonment and torture.

New York Times, 5 June 2005

No doubt this is the sort of person General Richard Myers had in mind when he claimed that Guantánamo detainees would “slit our children’s throats” if they were freed. See here.

Occupation main driver of suicide bombs

A surge in suicide attacks in Iraq and elsewhere around the world is a response to territorial occupation and has no direct link with so-called Islamic fundamentalism, an American writer said in a new book.

“Islamic fundamentalism is not the primary driver of suicide terrorism”, Robert Pape, associate professor of political science at the University of Chicago, told Reuters.

In his “Dying to Win: The Strategic Logic of Suicide Terrorism,” the American academician demonstrates to policymakers that a presumed connection between suicide attacks and the so-called Islamic fundamentalism is misleading and could contribute to policies that worsen the situation.

Continue reading

Liberal joins neocons in anti-Amnesty campaign

irenekhan2The speech by Amnesty general secretary Irene Khan describing Guantánamo as the “gulag of our times” (see here) reduced the US right to apoplexy. From Donald Rumsfeld down, they united to deny there was any parallel between incarcerating millions of Soviet citizens and locking up a mere 600 Muslims. See here, here, here, here, here and so ad infinitum.

Now here’s a test for you. Which journalist on a liberal Sunday newspaper could be relied upon to echo the anti-Amnesty propaganda of the US neocons?

Continue reading

Killing Al Jazeera journalists? ‘Oops’ chuckles Jihad Watch

Dima TahboubReuters reports: “The Arab TV channel Al Jazeera rejected on Saturday as unfounded Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld’s accusations that it was encouraging Islamic militant groups by airing beheadings of foreign hostages in Iraq. ‘Al Jazeera … has never at any time transmitted pictures of killings or beheadings and … any talk about this is absolutely unfounded,’ the television said in a statement.”

Commenting on the Reuters report, Jihad Watch declare their full support for Rumsfeld’s slanders and indicate that they’re quite comfortable with the idea of US forces launching air strikes against Al-Jazeera’s offices and killing its journalists.

Jihad Watch, 4 June 2005

Cf. Dima Tareq Tahboub, “The war on al-Jazeera”, Guardian, 4 October 2003